Reader Approved

How to Get Rid of Thistles

Thistles are very stubborn weeds, and if you do not catch them early on, they could take years to get rid of. With enough persistence, however, it is entirely possible to keep thistle in check without having to resort to drastic measures.

Part One of Three:
Organic Management
Edit

  1. 1
    Cut the thistle down. Once the thistle reaches its full grown stage, cut it down at its base. The thistle will pop back up eventually, but after cutting it down often enough, the roots will eventually become too stressed and the entire plant will wither.
    • While cutting and mowing are important all throughout the season, it is especially important to keep up on it during the first three to four weeks.
    • Cutting thistle down also prevents the thistles from drying out and leaving seeds.
    • With Canada thistle, regularly mowing and cutting the thistle down causes the thistle to starve to death. The rhizomes in the top portion of soil spread quickly, making the thistle hard to pull, but continual attacks on the thistle can stress the roots and make it impossible for the rhizomes to replenish their food supply.[1]
    • With bull thistle, trimming the thistle down only works if you can dig out the rosette formation during the first year. During the second year of this biennial plant, you need to cut the stems down to the ground before the thistle ever has a chance to bloom. If you let bull thistle flower, it will likely go to seed before you have any chance to stop it.
    • For creeping thistle, cut it down when the thistles are 4 to 6 inches (10 to 15.24 cm) long. Usually, this will be around early June. Cut it again when you next notice new shoots coming out.
    • If you want to improve the likelihood of stopping thistle in its tracks, wait until after the stalks are fully grown before you cut them back. Trimming the thistle early in the spring does not help much since the thistle will still be resilient enough to grow back. By waiting until just before they bud or immediately after unopened buds form, you stun the plant enough to severely inhibit later growth for the season.[2]
    • On the other hand, it is important that you trim thistle down before its buds open. Once the buds form and open, thistle can send out seeds. These seeds are carried on the wind very easily, which is one reason why thistle is such a stubborn weed.
    • When you cut thistle down, make sure that you throw away the clippings. Do not try to compost them since doing so can cause seeds and roots to spread, even if the plant has not officially gone to seed yet.
    • In addition to stressing the thistle, mowing your lawn also promotes healthy grass and makes the area less hospitable to new thistle plants. As such, thistle is less likely to spread through a trim, neat lawn.
  2. 2
    Dig out the root. If you only have a few thistle plants to worry about, you could dig out the entire root system by hand. This can be a time consuming practice since the root systems extend deep into the soil and spread wide, but if you are successfully able to get the entire root out, then you can get rid of the plant immediately.
    • Removing the thistle from the root is essential if you are dealing with bull thistle and not Canada thistle. While this process can help with Canada thistle, digging out the rosette of thistle during bull thistle's first year is a key part of keeping the weed under control.
    • Digging out the roots is especially helpful if you need to get rid of spear thistles or marsh thistles. These types of thistles have less extensive root systems in the early stages, so if you dig out the spud of the root at an early stage of growth, you might be able to remove enough of the roots to actually make a difference. The spud root will look like a rosette and lie just below the surface of the ground.
    • Always pull up as many of the roots as possible. Even broken roots can produce new plants, and since the broken roots are no longer connected to one another, they can actually cause even more thistle plants to pop up.
  3. 3
    Introduce natural predators. Certain types of mammals and insects eat thistle, and if you introduce these animals to your yard or pasture, they can keep the thistle population under control for you. After a while, the thistle will be so stressed that it will stop growing.
    • Insects that naturally attach thistle include the adult thistle-head weevil, thistle rosette weevil, thistle-stem gall fly, flower weevil, stem-mining weevil, yellow starthistle bud weevil, and yellow starthistle hairy weevil.[3]
    • Cattle will eat most species of non-poisonous thistle. Sheep and ponies tend to eat young thistle shoots, and goats, donkeys, and llamas eat creeping thistle at nearly any stage of growth.[4]
    Advertisement

Part Two of Three:
Herbicides
Edit

  1. 1
    Use a non-selective broadleaf herbicide. One of the surest ways to get rid of thistle is to apply a non-selective broadleaf herbicide to the entire area. The disadvantage is that all vegetation in that location will die, so this method should only be used if you are dealing with more thistle than you are yard.
    • Apply herbicides during seasons of active growth. These include spring and fall.
    • The best time to apply weed killer is on a sunny day, when the temperature is between 65 and 85 degrees Fahrenheit (18.3 and 29.4 degrees Celsius).
  2. 2
    Try an herbicide with glyphosate. When targeting individual thistle plants, it would be better to do so with an herbicide formulated with an ingredient like glyphosate. Apply this plant poison directly to the individual thistle plant by either spraying it or applying it by hand.
    • Apply herbicides during seasons of active growth. These include spring and fall.
    • Other popular herbicides known to work against thistle include MSMA, dicamba, MCPA, bromoxynil, and 2,4,-D.
    • While glyphosate and many other herbicides are technically non-selective, they can be applied specifically to the thistle, so you may not kill off any other plants in the area if you are careful enough.
    • To apply the herbicide by hand:[5]
      • Put on a thick rubber glove that is free from leaks.
      • Put a cotton glove over the rubber one.
      • Mix the herbicide in a container according to the instructions on the label.
      • Dip your gloved hand into the herbicide, just long enough to soak the cotton glove.
      • Make a fist over the container to drain excess herbicide.
      • Gently grasp each thistle, working from the bottom to the top of the plant, to apply a good dose of herbicide.
    • Note that you might need to apply herbicide multiple times before it completely wipes out the thistle.
  3. 3
    Hire a professional. Professional lawn care management companies have access to more powerful means of thistle extermination. They might use a stronger herbicide or try burning the thistle away.
    • If you want to try burning the thistle away, make sure that you hire professionals who are also licensed burn crews. Be aware that burning will probably kill the other plants in the area, as well, so it should only be used as a last resort.
    Advertisement

Part Three of Three:
Long-Term Prevention
Edit

  1. 1
    Pack other plants close together. To prevent more thistle from popping up, any plants you want in your yard or garden should be planted closely together. Doing so limits the amount of free space thistle has to take root in, thereby discouraging its growth.
    • Setting other plants close together attacks the thistle from both above and below. The root systems of the other plants can compete for nutrients with the thistle, thereby leaving fewer nutrients for the weed to drain. Tall plants can also create shade in the area, and since thistle hates shade, it will be less apt to grow in these new shady spots.
    • An especially good competitor plant for thistle is alfalfa. Alfalfa sprouts earlier than thistle does, so it can establish itself before thistle has a chance to do likewise.
    • Amend the soil in your garden or yard so that it suits the needs of the plants you want to grow rather than the needs of the thistle. Thistle grows well in soil with low fertility, so improving your soil with organic materials can discourage thistle growth while encouraging the growth of most other plants.[6]
  2. 2
    Remove any buds and flowers. If you are unable to completely mow down the thistle, you should at least cut any unopened buds and new flowers as soon as you spot them. By cutting the flowers off early, you can prevent the thistle from going to seed. When thistle plants cannot go to seed, they cannot spread, and new plants will not develop.
    • Difficulty can still arise if there is thistle nearby that you cannot control. For instance, if a neighbor has thistle in his or her yard and refuses to keep it in check, the seeds from that yard can still spread into yours via the wind.
  3. 3
    Spread mulch. If you have recently cut your thistle down or simply want to stop new thistle from growing, spreading a heavy layer of mulch over your garden or over bare spots in your yard can do the trick. Mulch makes it difficult for plants to access sunlight and blocks out many of the nutrients thistle needs to sprout and thrive.
    • Mulch can prevent new seeds from sprouting and may also keep any currently established root systems at bay as long as you have trimmed the growth back down to the ground before you apply mulch.
    • For mulch, consider using pine needles, shredded wood chips, or pecan hulls. Any standard mulch is fine, essentially, as long as you can apply a 2-inch (5-cm) covering of it.[7]
  4. 4
    Create a shady cover. Thistle thrives in sunlight and dies in shade. For long-term management, consider planting a large, shady tree in the area generally afflicted with thistle. For a shorter-term solution, construct a temporary shelter that can provide shade to thistle-infected areas.
    • Easy temporary structures can be made with tar paper, sheet metal, or cardboard boxes.
  5. 5
    Beware of contaminated materials. Organic materials you spread onto your lawn can contain thistle roots and clippings if you buy from an untrustworthy source. When you buy organic materials, make sure that the seller has a good reputation.
    • Materials to watch out for include grass seeds, mulching material, and animal feed.
    Advertisement

Community Q&A

Search
Add New Question
  • Can I burn dead thistle that's been removed from the ground?
    Answered by wikiHow Contributor
    • Yes, you can burn dead thistle. Place the weeds in a pile, let them dry for a day or so, and then ignite them with an accelerant. This is a good way to dispose of the plant and any seeds.
    Thanks! 4 0
  • If I cut down mature thistles and use a spectracide, will that ensure that the roots are killed and the plant won't come back?
    Answered by wikiHow Contributor
    • Make a salt water solution of 25% salt. Dissolve it in hot water to be sure all of the salt is dissolved. Clip the thistle about 2/3 inches above the ground and put a small amount of the solution into the center of the stub that is left. This will kill off the root system in total and make it so it will not come back.
    Thanks! 51 27
  • Can I use household items, like bleach or vinegar, for instance?
    Answered by wikiHow Contributor
    • You could, but that alone won't solve the problem, and you should follow the steps in the article.
    Thanks! 6 5
  • What do I do once I have killed the thistle?
    Answered by wikiHow Contributor
    • After you have killed the thistle, keep an eye out just in case it grows back. I would recommend pulling the roots up to decrease the chances of this.
    Thanks! 1 0
  • Once I have gotten rid of all above-ground thistle, how do I kill the rhizomes? I don't want to be selective. I want to kill everything in this area so I can plant grass, hopefully, next year.
    Answered by Donagan, Top Answerer
    • Some commercial applications (such as Roundup) will kill rhizomes if applied to the leaves.
    Thanks! 8 16
  • How do I kill Canada thistle that is growing in my creeping prostrate juniper?
  • I have a big hill with crown vetch covering. Thistles are taking over the hill. Is there a spray I can use that will kill thistles but not crown vetch?
  • Will bleach kill them?
  • Will 2-4-D sprayed on dry thistle seeds prohibit germination?
  • How do you treat large clumps of evergreen bushes taken over by thistle? The clumps also shelter feral cats. So nothing toxic.
Show more unanswered questions
Ask a Question
200 characters left
Include your email address to get a message when this question is answered.
Submit

TipsEdit

  • To improve your odds, use multiple methods of thistle removal instead of relying on one at a time.
    0 Helpful?  0
  • Wear gloves when handling thistle. Standard gardening gloves might be too thin and you may find yourself getting scratched up. If this is the case, try using welders' gloves, which are made of much thicker material.
    0 Helpful?  0
Add

Things You'll NeedEdit

  • Shears
  • Lawn mower
  • Trowel
  • Thistle weevils, cattle, goats, and other thistle-eating animals
  • Broadleaf herbicide
  • Glyphosate herbicide
  • Thick rubber glove
  • Thick cotton glove
  • Welders' gloves
  • Bucket
  • Competitor plants
  • Mulch
  • Shady structure or cover

Made Recently

3 years ago
Loading...
Add a photo
Upload error
Awesome picture! Tell us more about it? Click here to share your story.

About This Article

20 votes - 96%
Co-authors: 11
Updated:
Views: 242,542

Reader Success Stories

  • BF

    Barb Fischer

    Aug 6, 2016

    "I have an abundant thistle crop in my landscaping (flower beds). Completely out of control, no matter how much pulling I do. What a waste of my life. I am going to use the information about the herbicides, especially the suggestion of hand application, since the thistles are growing near and among the flowers and shrubs. I am hopeful this will help a lot."..." more
  • DB

    Dahlia Betancourt

    Aug 23, 2016

    "I got thistle weed everywhere and it's hurting my dogs, but when I was weeding the thistles went right through my gloves. Your suggestion to get thicker gloves helped a lot because thistles were hurting me too, ouch!"..." more
  • SS

    Susan S.

    Jun 6, 2016

    "I have read and read about removal of thistle. This article gives every management solution in a clear and easy to read manner. Thank you. Are there side effects to introducing natural predators?"..." more
  • EZ

    Ellie Zoller

    Oct 15, 2017

    "It gave me practical solutions to get rid of these ugly things in the garden. Former owner did not take care of them, so there are a multitude among lovely flowers."..." more
  • BK

    Beth Kow

    Apr 16, 2017

    "I think alfalfa just became my best friend. We have cut and sprayed and fought for 5 years. The grass is gone. It's all pickers. No one ever suggested this. "..." more
    Rated this article:
  • AA

    Aldee Ablo

    Jun 6, 2016

    "Clear easy step-by-step instructions, gives a number of options, with illustrations, and is very specific about the differences in these weeds! Great Job!!"..." more
  • CL

    Claire Lambert

    Aug 4, 2017

    "We never had thistle until this year. I will try cutting them off. I sprayed vinegar on them today. I put poison on them earlier, but they came back."..." more
    Rated this article:
  • LL

    Lisa Lee

    Aug 26, 2016

    "I didn't have any idea what the plant was. I'm going to follow everything I learned in this page. Very helpful, thank you so very much! "..." more
  • PV

    Peter Vadas

    Jun 25, 2017

    "A person never knows enough about eradicating thistle. I did not know there were so many verities. This was a big help."..." more
  • BW

    Betty Wright

    Jul 8, 2016

    "I have looked through many articles and this one was the most informative. Thank you."
  • MB

    Mary Baker

    Jun 1, 2016

    "Liked the information on safely removing thistle plants from my flower bed."
  • AN

    Ashley Norris

    Oct 25, 2016

    "This article helped by telling me how I can control bull thistles."
  • SC

    S. C.

    Apr 9, 2016

    "A good, informative article."
  • KD

    Kelli Durgan

    Apr 25, 2017

    "It was a great help."
    Rated this article:
Share your story

Did this article help you?

Yes
No